Skip to content
Harobanda

The gap

Three kinds of operating system — and you control none of them.

Whatever you run today is one of three, and each takes the floor away from you in its own way.

the commercial OS

Shaped by a business model

The account you sign in with, the store you cannot remove, the telemetry you cannot see, the update you cannot refuse, the support that ends on a date someone else picks. None of it serves your job — it serves the vendor's revenue, and the forest of apps you must install is the product.

the open-source distribution

Free to read, still not yours

Even a free system is governed by the company that curates it. You inherit its package repositories, its defaults and its release calendar; you keep a plugin ecosystem alive; you live in dependency hell, where upgrading one thing moves ten others. Free is not the same as sovereign.

the phone OS

Hardware and software, fused

The sharpest case. The vendor welds the two together so tightly that you cannot run your own system on their device, and cannot have their device's abilities on hardware you chose. The user — and the designer — is closed inside a link neither can open.

What sits inside
Their OS — commercial or a curated distribution
Harobanda
An account to sign in
Required, tied to the vendor
None. No identity anyone else holds
A store & a package manager
Built in; a jungle to install and maintain
None. Nothing is installed at run time
Dependencies
A graph you must keep satisfied; things break each other
The machine is one closed image; nothing to resolve
Updates
Pushed, or a risky upgrade you run by hand
A new image, tried once, rolled back by hardware if wrong
The bootloader & the hardware
Vendor-controlled; on phones, welded to the software
Ordinary hardware you chose; the machine is your own source
End of support
A date the vendor or the distro picks
No vendor to end it